Panel Consideration Meeting - Cancellation Application - Teacher B
Definitions
Any reference in this decision to:
- ‘GTC Scotland’ means the General Teaching Council for Scotland;
- the ‘Panel’ means the Fitness to Teach Panel considering the case; and
- the ‘Rules’ (and any related expression) means the GTC Scotland Fitness to Teach Rules 2017 or refers to a provision (or provisions) within them.
Allegations
- On or around 7 August 2022, whilst employed by [redacted] as [redacted] at [redacted], the Teacher did instruct Individual A to remove filing cabinets containing files holding confidential data relating to Additional Support Needs (ASN) pupils from the school.
- On an unknown date in 2022, whilst employed by [redacted] as [redacted] at [redacted], the Teacher did give Individual A access to files containing confidential data relating ASN pupils, (specifically the records referred to at allegation 1), and ask him to deliver them to Individual C.
- On an unknown date in 2022, whilst employed by [redacted] as [redacted] at [redacted], the Teacher did give Individual A access to a file containing confidential data relating to a pupil and ask him to deliver it to Individual B.
- On a date or dates unknown between September 2020 and September 2022, whilst employed by [redacted] as [redacted] at [redacted], the Teacher did arrange for and/or allow Individual A, who is not a registered teacher, to deliver the Physical Education (PE) curriculum to pupils without a registered teacher being present.
And in light of the above, it is alleged that the Teacher’s fitness to teach is impaired and/or she is unfit to teach as a result of breaching Parts 1.3, 2.1,2.4, and 4.5 GTC Scotland’s Code of Professionalism and Conduct 2012.
Background
The meeting was arranged to consider the following:
- An application submitted on behalf of the Teacher, dated 30 June 2026
Evidence
In accordance with Rule 1.7.17, the Panel admitted all of the documents and statements listed below as evidence for the purposes of the hearing:
- Case Cancellation Procedural Form, dated 16 July 2026
- Case Cancellation Application, dated June 2026 and received by GTCS 30 June 2026
- [redacted], dated June 2026
- Interim Investigation Report, dated 1 April 2024
- Teacher's Response to Interim Investigation Report, dated 28 June 2024
- Final Investigation Report and Appendices, dated 30 October 2025
- Teacher's Response to Final Investigation Report, dated 1 December 2025 (email chain)
- Presenting Officer’s response, dated 15 July 2026
- Teacher’s final comments, dated 16 July 2026
Preliminary Matters
The Panel carefully considered the terms of Rule 2.5.1:
At any stage of proceedings, a Panel of its own volition, on the Convener’s direction or upon the application of a party (in such form as may be specified by the Servicing Officer), may:
(a) determine any interim or preliminary matter that has arisen in the case;
(b) resolve any issues of law; or
(c) consider an application for a case to be cancelled.
The Panel further noted that this was a conduct case and that the relevant rule is 2.10.9 of the GTC Scotland Fitness to Teach Rules. This states that:
A Panel may at any time following the referral of a case to it for a hearing decide to cancel a case (and dispose of it on that basis). Before making any such decision, a Panel must have heard from the parties on the matter and be satisfied that it is in accordance with the general objective and in the public interest to do so.
The Panel noted that neither of the Parties requested the procedural hearing in the submissions made. Further to this, the Panel considered that a procedural hearing was not necessary.
Therefore, the Panel proceeded to consider the matter on the papers.
Application
An application dated 30 June 2026, for the present Fitness to Teach proceedings brought against the teacher to be cancelled in terms of Rule 2.10.9 of the General Teaching Council for Scotland Fitness to Teach Rules 2017.
Submissions on behalf of the Teacher
It was the Teacher’s position that the case should be cancelled based on [redacted]. The submissions also addressed the public interest and concluded that the application for cancellation on the basis of Rule 2.10.9 should be granted.
Submissions on behalf of the Presenting Officer
The Presenting Officer’s submissions accept the [redacted].
The Presenting Officer also accedes to the view that the allegations are not at the more serious end of the spectrum.
The Presenting Officer states that GTC Scotland is ‘neutral’ on the case being cancelled.
Decision
Firstly, the Panel had regard to the [redacted].
[redacted].
General Objective and the Public Interest
That being the case the Panel considered the general objective and the public interest. The Panel noted Rule 1.3.7:
These rules have the general objective of enabling GTC Scotland, Conveners and Panels, with the assistance of the parties, to deal with cases fairly and justly.
And also noted that as per Rule 1.3.8 this meant:
Dealing with a case fairly and justly includes, so far as practicable, dealing with it in ways which:
(a) are proportionate to the complexity of the issues;
(b) seek informality and flexibility in proceedings;
(c) ensure that parties are able to participate fully in proceedings; and
(d) avoid delay, so far as compatible with the proper consideration of the issues
In considering the application the Panel took into consideration the above rules.
Firstly, the Panel was of the view that the allegations in this case were at the lower end of the spectrum in terms of their seriousness. It did not minimise the alleged conduct but did weigh its seriousness against the [redacted] and reached the view that the impact that proceeding to a hearing in this case would have on the Teacher outweighed the public interest in proceeding. The Panel noted that these proceedings had been ongoing in one form or another for approximately six years and that the conduct forming the allegations had occurred as long ago as 2020. In the view of the Panel the attenuated nature of the proceedings means that their proceeding is now serving no real purpose other than [redacted]. The Panel considered that an ordinary member of the public, cognisant of all the relevant facts including the duration of these proceedings, and the impact they have had and continue to have [redacted], would not think it inappropriate for this case to be dismissed of by way of cancellation.
After careful consideration of all the above factors the Panel, in accordance with Rule 2.10.9, having heard from both parties and being satisfied that it was in line with the general objective and in the public interest, decided to grant the application made on behalf of the Teacher and dispose of this case by cancellation.