Panel Consideration Meeting - Anonymity Application - Teacher B
Definitions
Any reference in this decision to:
- ‘GTC Scotland’ means the General Teaching Council for Scotland;
- the ‘Panel’ means the Fitness to Teach Panel considering the case; and
- the ‘Rules’ (and any related expression) means the GTC Scotland Fitness to Teach Rules 2017 or refers to a provision (or provisions) within them.
Background
The Panel Meeting was arranged to consider an application for anonymisation on behalf of the Teacher.
Evidence
In accordance with rule 1.7.17, the Panel admitted all of the documents and statements listed below as evidence for the purposes of the meeting:
- Anonymity application, dated 31 August 2026, with appendices including:
- Case Cancellation Decision, dated 7 August 2026
- [redacted] Report, dated 17 June 2026
Preliminary matters
No preliminary matters were raised.
Application
An application, dated 31 August 2026, was made on behalf of the Teacher seeking anonymisation/redaction of her name and GTC Scotland registration number in any written decision(s) of GTC Scotland. This was made pursuant to a Case Cancellation Decision, dated 7 August 2026.
Submissions
The Teacher’s representative made a detailed written submission with reference to the 2017 Rules, the GTC Scotland Privacy and Anonymity Practice Statement and Articles 6, 8 and 10 ECHR. It was submitted that the exception in Article 6 allowing privacy or anonymity “where the protection of the private life of the party so requires” was engaged.
It was submitted that a Case Cancellation Application made on behalf of the Teacher had been granted by a Panel on 7 August 2026. The primary reason for granting the Application had been the [redacted] evidence produced on behalf of the Teacher [redacted]. The Panel had also noted the allegations were historic and further at the lower end of the spectrum and as such fell to be weighed against the significance of the [redacted] evidence. It had concluded that the impact of a hearing on the Teacher would outweigh the public interest in proceeding.
Reference was made to an independent [redacted] report submitted for the case cancellation application which also dealt with the question of anonymity. The expert had concluded that publicity and publication of a GTC Scotland decision would be [redacted] to the Teacher. [redacted]. This [redacted] was a more than compelling reason to grant the application. This was not a situation where a registrant sought to avoid embarrassment or reputational damage. The Teacher [redacted] that have worsened as a result of the current proceedings. Even though the outcome had been cancellation, the risk of publication remained salient. It would not be in the public interest to name the Teacher in the case cancellation decision given the historic and relatively less serious nature of the allegations. It would not be proportionate to name the Teacher in the circumstances. A fully informed member of the public would not consider it necessary, reasonable, or proportionate to do so given the risk publication [redacted].
Procedural and legal advice
The Servicing Officer firstly advised the Panel that there was no Presenting Officer response and they should consider the merits of the Application based on the submissions of the Teacher. He reminded the Panel that the GTC Scotland default position is full publication of decisions to ensure open justice. He drew the Panel’s attention to the terms of the GTC Scotland Privacy and Anonymity Practice Statement and the need to carry out a balancing exercise in terms of ECHR Articles 6 and 8. Any order for anonymity would be made by exception on the basis the Panel was satisfied it was in the interests of justice that this should outweigh the public interest in publication. As [redacted] supporting information had been produced, he also drew the Panel’s attention to the GTC Scotland Practice Statement on [redacted] in evaluating this evidence.
The Legal Assessor reminded the Panel of Rule 1.7.3(b) of the Rules which provides that a Panel may, at any stage of proceedings, make an order with a view to preventing or restricting the public disclosure of any aspect of proceedings. It may do this as far as it considers it necessary to do so where it is satisfied (having given parties the opportunity to make representations) that (i) it is in the interests of justice to do so and (ii) the particular circumstances of the case outweigh the interests of the Teacher and the public of the hearing being held in public. The Panel must decide whether to exercise its discretion to grant such a request bearing in mind that it should do so only to the extent it considers necessary. There are no limitations in the Rules to the specific terms of such an order, but the Rules contemplate the type of order sought by the Teacher insofar as they provide that a Panel may make an order “that the identities of specified parties, witnesses or other persons referred to in the proceedings should not be disclosed at such proceedings to the public (by the use of anonymisation or otherwise) and whether before, during or after those proceedings” (Rule 1.7.3(b).
Orders allowing privacy or anonymity should be made by exception and with regard to the terms of Article 6 ECHR. This provides, as far as relevant here, that the public may be excluded “where the protection of the private life of the parties so requires” or “to the extent strictly necessary in the opinion of the court [the Panel] in special circumstances where publicity would prejudice the interests of justice”. However, the public interest is not absolute (GMC v X 2019 EWCH 493 (Admin)). A significant risk to the registrant may outweigh the public interest in publication. The Panel requires to consider harm to other legitimate interests such as the registrant’s Convention rights as far as these are engaged and perform a balancing exercise (Dixon v North Bristol NHS Trust [2022] EWCH 1871 (QB)). She offered the summary that “a registrant seeking to prevent … publication of a determination after a hearing will need to show cogent evidence of serious harm or disproportionate damage” (Hamer, para 68.28).
Rules 1.3.7, 1.3.8 and 1.3.9 further direct that Panels must deal with cases fairly and justly.
Finally, the Legal Advisor drew the Panel’s attention to the case [redacted].
Decision
The Panel considered the supporting expert [redacted] evidence provided on behalf of the Teacher. It noted that the requirements of the relevant Practice Statement had been complied with as far as a [redacted] had been provided; the Teacher’s [redacted] appeared to be [redacted]; and the expert had set out how the prospect of publication would affect the Teacher. The Panel took the view that there was significant concern for the Teacher’s [redacted] in light of this evidence. There was unequivocal evidence of a real and immediate [redacted] should the Application not be granted.
On this basis, the Panel was persuaded that the Teacher’s Article 2 and 8 rights outweighed the presumption of open justice and as such it was necessary and proportionate to grant the Application.
The Panel therefore directed that the Teacher’s name and GTC Scotland Registration Number be redacted from the Case Cancellation Decision and any other decision issued in respect of the present proceedings.